OrbitalHub

Where curiosity reaches escape velocity.

Domain is for sale. $50,000,000.00 USD. Direct any inquiries to contact@orbitalhub.com.

 

V445 Puppis: the Milky Way's only helium nova, finally exposed after 25 years in the dust. Image: 2026 07 25 v445 puppis helium nova bullets.

 

A white dwarf does not need to do anything dramatic to set the record books of stellar astrophysics. It only needs to wait. For V445 Puppis, the wait ended this week when a team led by John Mills at the University of Warwick finally traced the system back to its ingredients: a compact stellar corpse pulling material from a rare stripped helium star. The RAS press release for the Royal Astronomical Society’s National Astronomy Meeting in Birmingham described the result, and it pinned down what astronomers have wondered about since November 2000, when a point of light in the constellation Puppis brightened and then vanished behind its own debris.

The eruption produced a bipolar outflow stretching more than 1.5 trillion kilometers, with clumps of gas clocked at roughly 8,900 kilometers per second, about 3% of the speed of light, racing through the ejecta. The press release calls them “bullets” and notes that nothing of their kind has ever been seen in any other nova.

Almost every nova we know about is hydrogen-rich. A white dwarf siphons gas from a Sun-like companion, the stolen layer gets compressed and hot, and a thermonuclear runaway on the white dwarf’s surface flashes the system into view. The whole cycle takes a few weeks to a few years, then the dwarf goes back to feeding. Helium novae are different in a way that sounds like physics trivia but is genuinely awkward for the textbooks: the accreting layer contains almost no hydrogen at all. The fuel has been swapped out, and only a handful of candidates in the Milky Way match that description. V445 Puppis, the only one currently confirmed, is essentially the only laboratory on hand for studying what such an explosion actually looks like before, during, and after.

That matters because helium novae are one of the proposed pathways to Type Ia supernovae. White dwarfs that keep accreting material approach the Chandrasekhar mass limit, where the star can no longer support itself against electron degeneracy, and the result is one of the most important kinds of explosion in observational cosmology. Type Ia supernovae are the standard candles behind the 1998 discovery of the accelerating expansion of the universe, the work honored by the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics. Understanding their progenitors is one of the standing problems in stellar astrophysics, and helium novae sit on one of the more plausible candidate routes.

The same logic explains why a 25-year wait is not the embarrassment it sounds like. The eruption’s own dust disk made any direct view of the central binary impossible through optical and ultraviolet light, and the only way to see through was to wait for the obscuring veil to thin enough for a new generation of instruments. That window has now opened.

V445 Puppis erupted in late November 2000 and was classified almost immediately as a nova, although the spectrum looked strange from the start. There was helium, carbon, and a long list of heavier elements, but essentially no hydrogen, the element that defines nearly every other nova on record. For the next 25 years the system sat inside a thick dust torus, bright in the infrared from the re-radiated light of the eruption but stubbornly opaque at the wavelengths where stellar spectra carry information about the two stars at its center.

The new result came from a deliberate effort to combine four observatories. Mills pulled infrared images from the European Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope, optical images from the Hubble Space Telescope’s Wide Field Camera 3, long-term spectroscopy from the Southern African Large Telescope, and photometric monitoring from NASA’s TESS satellite. The four cover the infrared through visible bands, plus time-resolved brightness measurements that make it possible to extract the orbital period. John Mills’ research page at the University of Warwick describes the same approach in his group’s broader work on hot and cool binaries.

With the dust clear enough, the spectrum showed strong ionized helium lines consistent with material actively falling back onto the white dwarf. The brightness curve gave an orbital period of 3.7 days, about twice the value the most widely cited prior estimate had produced. A 2023 paper in The Astrophysical Journal Letters, “V445 Puppis: Dustier than a Thousand Novae,” had estimated the eruption threw off between 0.01 and 0.1 solar masses of gas, which would actually mean the white dwarf is losing mass over repeated eruptions rather than approaching a Type Ia explosion. The 3.7-day orbit and the active accretion add two more data points to that open debate.

Embedded inside the bipolar outflow, the Hubble imaging also resolved distinct compact knots of gas, possibly oxygen-rich, moving at speeds comparable to the fastest ejecta ever measured in a classical nova. The RAS announcement explicitly notes that no analogous structures have been observed in any other nova, which is why Mills flagged the origin of the bullets as the unresolved problem in the talk.

The work was reported at NAM 2026 in Birmingham on Wednesday 22 July 2026, in a talk titled “Long-term evolution of the helium nova V445 Puppis and the emergence of the underlying binary.” As of this writing the results have not yet gone through formal peer review, a point Universe Magazine’s coverage makes explicit, but the data sources themselves are public and the orbital measurement should be straightforward to confirm.

A classical nova does not destroy the white dwarf; the explosion only blows off the freshly accreted surface layer. The energy budget is well understood: hydrogen-rich material piles up under degenerate conditions, the base reaches roughly 10 million K, and a CNO-cycle hot layer drives the runaway. The peak luminosity is comparable to a small star, which is why distant novae can briefly outshine the combined light of their host galaxies.

Helium novae follow the same broad pattern with hydrogen-poor fuel, and the mechanics are fuzzier because so few examples exist. The white dwarf in V445 Puppis cannot be accreting hydrogen-rich gas, which is what motivates the “stripped helium star” companion model, a star that has already lost its hydrogen envelope through prior interaction. The models get the orbital period, the spectral lines, and the mass loss to line up at least approximately, although the geometry of how the white dwarf pulls material off its donor’s outer layers is still being worked out.

The bullet problem is the genuinely new piece. A 2009 infrared study had identified clumps moving at 6,700 km/s in a narrow hourglass-shaped outflow, with knots at 8,450 km/s. Mills’ combined analysis finds similar speeds and identifies discrete oxygen-rich clumps at roughly 8,900 km/s, fast enough to cross the Earth-Moon distance in under five minutes. The knots are not fast enough to be a separate explosion, but they are too fast to be passive material carried by a slow wind, which is why the team assumes some kind of post-eruption engine. So far none of the obvious candidates, including a re-ignition on the white dwarf surface and gravitational rebound, cleanly fits both the timing and the composition.

The imaging pipeline is the more straightforward part. Hubble’s WFC3 narrow-band filters F502N, F680N, and FQ727N isolate the emission from ionized oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur separately, which is what made the oxygen identification possible. Combining frames from two different epochs (2013 and 2015) let the team measure proper motion of each knot directly.

After more than two decades behind a self-built dust wall, V445 Puppis is now visible as what it has been all along: a white dwarf feeding helium-rich gas from a rare stripped companion. The 3.7-day orbital period replaces the older 1.87-day estimate, the dust mass loss points toward a white dwarf that is being drained rather than grown by each eruption, and a catalog of fast oxygen-rich knots has no clean explanation yet.

The next obvious step is a longer TESS baseline plus higher-cadence UV spectroscopy with HST. If the binary truly is no longer accreting efficiently, the 2023 dust-mass argument gains weight and the path to a Type Ia supernova through this channel looks harder than it did five years ago. If the bullets can be linked to a specific instability, the same mechanism probably applies to a few helium-rich extragalactic novae that have otherwise looked like clean hydrogen-poor events. Either way, V445 Puppis has stopped being a curiosity and started being a test.

 

 

A long-exposure photograph of a SpaceX Falcon 9 climbing through the pre-dawn sky from Cape Canaveral, the exhaust plume forming a bright diagonal streak through scattered cloud above silhouetted palm trees. Source: SpaceX, via the Bandwagon-5 mission page. Full-size file: https://sxcontent9668.azureedge.us/cms-assets/assets/20261020_CC_Band_5_DSC_0759_desktop_81035d0e4c.jpg

 

At 7:04 a.m. EDT on Tuesday, October 20, a Falcon 9 lifted off from Space Launch Complex 40 at Cape Canaveral carrying 32 payloads. The one that mattered most to the company flying it was its own hardware. Starfall, a broad, uncrewed reentry capsule, went up for the second time in its life and left the rocket last, separating from the second stage two hours and 48 minutes after liftoff, once the commercial satellites were gone (Space.com). By 8:45 a.m. EDT SpaceX had confirmed every customer payload was deployed (Spaceflight Now). What the company did not say, and has not said since, is what Starfall carried, how long it stayed up, or what happened on the way down. The same company that publishes booster flight counts to the digit has treated this vehicle with the discretion usually reserved for something it does not want competitors reading.

The most detailed public description of the capsule is not a SpaceX document. It is the environmental assessment the company filed with the Federal Aviation Administration in May to get permission for the flight, and that document treats Starfall as infrastructure rather than as a spacecraft demonstration. The filing gives two reasons for the program: moving urgent cargo point to point, and building an orbital manufacturing economy by selling time in microgravity and vacuum with a ride home, what the assessment calls safe return from orbit as a service at scale. Each unit is a short cylinder about 0.75 meters tall and 3.1 meters across, roughly 2,100 kilograms empty, rated to carry 1,000 kilograms of payload down to the surface, for about 3,100 kilograms with a load aboard. A graphic shown in SpaceX’s initial public offering roadshow material appears to depict a satellite bus with slots for as many as four capsules, labelled for manufacturing in orbit (Spaceflight Now on the June debut). Whether that bus ever flies is a different question from whether the capsules do. The permission itself is small: the assessment covers two reentries into a Pacific recovery zone, which means the flights that have happened are the entire scope of what SpaceX currently has authorization for. A service business needs a licensing footprint built well ahead of the first customer invoice, and there is no public sign of that footprint yet.

The manner of the June debut is the best explanation for the current reticence. SpaceX kept the payload off the public manifest until close to flight, shared a rendering rather than hardware photography, and cut its public timeline after the booster landing so that neither the upper stage nor the capsule appeared in the broadcast. When deployment was confirmed that morning, the company had not disclosed how many capsules were aboard. On October 20 the capsule again rode to orbit among dozens of unrelated smallsats, again last to separate, again without a stated payload. Two flights in, the public record describes the vehicle’s architecture in detail and its missions not at all.

The ride itself was routine by SpaceX standards and the manifest was not. The launch had been scrubbed the previous morning over weather in the booster recovery zone, and the 45th Weather Squadron gave the Tuesday window a 90 percent chance of acceptable conditions. The rocket flew southeast, and booster B1085, on its nineteenth flight, came down on the droneship A Shortfall of Gravitas about nine minutes after liftoff. Twenty of the thirty-one commercial payloads were manifested by Exolaunch, among them four radio-frequency monitoring satellites for HawkEye 360, four communications satellites for the Finnish firm Iceye, and six navigation satellites for Xona Space Systems. Planet flew an Earth-observation satellite called Pelican-12. Portal Space Systems used the ride to demonstrate Starburst-1, a 260 kg spacecraft with room for a 50 kg customer payload, with commercial flights advertised from 2027, a mix the company describes on its Bandwagon-5 mission page as cubesats and microsats (Spaceflight Now).

The most interesting neighbor on that manifest was Varda’s W-Series 7 capsule, about three times smaller than Starfall, carrying a cancer drug called Protac to test whether microgravity produces crystal forms with better solubility. The flight was Varda’s ninth capsule launched despite the number in its name, following W-8 and W-9 on the Transporter-18 mission earlier in October. Two returning capsules on one rocket, one of them operated by a startup that has been doing this routinely while SpaceX works quietly on its own, tells you something about where the industry actually sits. Bandwagon is the quieter of SpaceX’s two rideshare programs. Transporter has flown eighteen missions, and the first in January 2021 delivered 143 payloads in a single launch, a record that still stands.

The design is where the vehicle stops looking like a spacecraft and starts looking like a product, and the constraints live there too. According to the FAA assessment, Starfall carries no main propulsion system. It has an attitude control system that uses inert gas to orient the craft, which means it can point itself but cannot perform a deorbit burn, so it cannot shorten its own stay in orbit or choose where it comes down (Spaceflight Now). With no engine to light, the only brake available is atmosphere, which makes the capsule’s blunt shape less a styling choice than the thing that lets it survive the trip: a wide body presents a lot of area to slowing air, and the assessment notes the capsules can fly either a low Earth orbit or a suborbital profile, on a Falcon 9 or on Starship. Orbital energy sets the heat load, so the shape that handles the steepest possible reentry is the one that can also handle the shallowest. The capsule is built in two pieces that separate after reentry: an aluminum top plate partially wrapped in thermal protection material, about 1,400 kilograms, and a carbon-fiber heat shield of roughly 700 kilograms holding two large compressed nitrogen bottles of 151 liters each plus several smaller auxiliary bottles. Lifting the top plate exposes the parachute, and there are three of them, a drogue, a pilot and a main, attached at four reinforced points. Recovery happens in the Pacific, the same ocean used for Dragon. The June flight reportedly validated the capsule’s autonomous guidance before a targeted splashdown (SatNews).

Two flights is a test program, not a service. What SpaceX has not established is the cadence, the price, or whether any paying customer has boarded, and the absence of a named payload on the second flight suggests the answer to the last question is still no. The competitors are not standing still: Varda has flown nine capsules and is running pharmaceutical experiments on them, and Portal is building a vehicle that does the same orbital delivery job for small payloads. What would move Starfall from demonstration to business is not a third flight but the paperwork that follows one, since the current authorization covers exactly two reentries. Until SpaceX files for more and names a customer, the accurate description of the capsule is the one the company keeps declining to give.

 

 

Layered beige Martian rocks at the Jawbone Canyon site in Gale crater, photographed by NASA's Curiosity rover on Sol 4391 (December 12, 2024), showing the stacked wind ripple laminations interpreted as supercritical climbing wind ripple strata.

 

Somewhere around 3.6 billion years ago, on what was probably an unremarkable afternoon, a sandstorm rolled into Gale crater on Mars. It may have lasted only hours. By the next day, the wind was back to normal and the surface was a sunlit desert again. No one saw it. Nothing else on the planet recorded it. But the storm left a physical imprint, and NASA’s Curiosity rover drove past that imprint on December 12, 2024, on its 4,391st Martian day, and photographed it (NASA Science Photojournal, July 20 2026).

The imprint is now the cover paper of the July 1, 2026 issue of the journal Geology. A team led by Steven Banham of Imperial College London describes millimeter-thick, crinkly laminations inside a rock the rover team nicknamed “Jawbone Canyon,” in the Mirador formation on the lower slopes of Mount Sharp. The structures are supercritical climbing wind ripple strata: a class of wind-deposited layering so rare on Earth that sedimentologists have only documented it in a handful of modern and ancient settings, and never before on another planet (Banham et al. 2026, Geology 54(7):611, DOI 10.1130/G54158.1).

Mars climate science has long had a sandstorm problem. Orbital cameras have shown that dust devils and regional dust storms lift fines off the surface today. Climate models assume that early Mars had a thicker atmosphere capable of moving sand. But the physical evidence for sustained sand-moving winds on ancient Mars has been almost entirely indirect: cross-bedded sandstones that record long-term wind patterns, dune fields that froze into rock, ventifacts worn by saltation.

Those records cannot resolve a single weather event. A climbing wind ripple is the signature of a wind strong enough, lasting long enough, and carrying enough sand that the ripples could not migrate as fast as new sand arrived. The crests piled up on the stoss side instead of sliding down the lee side. Each millimeter-thick lamina is the trace of a burst of sand transport; the climb angle records how fast sediment accumulated relative to how fast the bedform moved. The team measured angles of 10 to 18 degrees, values the paper says can only be produced by storms lasting minutes to hours, not by seasonal winds over thousands of years.

That makes the Jawbone Canyon outcrop the first direct physical evidence of a sandstorm on Mars. The paper’s wording is measured: “These climbing ripple sets occur in a thin succession, which suggests that they record a broader sustained event, such as a sandstorm or gale, lasting several hours or more.” The phrase is doing real work, because the alternative explanations had to be ruled out one by one. The central argument is a negative: ordinary wind regimes cannot deposit climbing ripples of these thicknesses at these angles, so whatever made them had to be stronger than everyday wind.

A secondary argument reaches further. Banham notes in the paper and in press interviews that the modern Martian atmosphere, at roughly 6 millibars of mean surface pressure, is too thin to drive saltation at the scale required to build these structures (Astrobiology.com, April 4 2026). The deposits imply that the atmosphere three and a half billion years ago was denser than today’s. The exact density is not pinned down, but the qualitative conclusion is clear: the air on early Mars was heavy enough to push sand in ways the present-day air cannot.

The find was not part of any planned observation. Curiosity’s science team operates in shifts, and one of the standing tasks is to scan the black-and-white navigation panoramas taken at the end of each drive for anything anomalous. Banham and his collaborators, including Linda Kah of the University of Tennessee, Joel Davis of Imperial College London, Sanjeev Gupta, Gerhard Paar, and several JPL-Caltech sedimentologists and mission scientists, noticed unusual textures in those panoramas as the rover approached the Mirador formation. They targeted the rocks with the higher-resolution Mastcam, and at full resolution the laminations resolved into the climbing ripple patterns.

Banham described the find as serendipitous: “We weren’t really looking for these deposits, and then lo and behold, we drove around the corner and found them. We were lucky that we had just the right people on shift that recognized them.” The rock itself is modest in size, roughly a meter wide and 20 centimeters high, with six discrete packages of ripple layers stacked through its thickness. The laminae dip toward the north, which means the wind that built them came from the south. Similar climbing ripples were later identified at a nearby site the team named Dry Lake, and the paper argues that the deposits formed near the margin of a larger dune field or in a wind-scoured depression where airflow patterns concentrated sand accumulation.

The discovery is also a vindication of the Mastcam team’s instinct to keep taking high-resolution follow-up imagery of “unusual” textures. Climbing ripples this small could have been mistaken for noise in lower-resolution data, or simply dismissed as weathered outcrop. The fact that a thin succession of six packages survived in one place for over three billion years, exposed at the surface for the rover to roll up to, is its own piece of good fortune.

The terminology is precise. In sedimentology, ripples are small bedforms, typically a few centimeters tall and tens of centimeters in wavelength, that form when wind or water flows over a bed of loose sand and organizes it into regular undulations. In a normal subcritical regime, sand grains saltate up the windward (stoss) face and avalanche down the leeward (lee) face, and the ripple migrates downwind without growing vertically. In a supercritical regime, the wind is strong enough and the sand supply is high enough that grains accumulate faster on the stoss face than they can slide off the lee face, so the ripple climbs. The climb angle is set by the ratio of vertical accumulation to horizontal migration; a 10-degree angle corresponds to roughly six times as much vertical deposition as horizontal migration.

Climbing ripples have been documented in a small number of terrestrial settings: deep-sea turbidity currents, certain wind-blown dune margins, and a few fluvial flood deposits. They are rare because the conditions that produce them are themselves unusual. On Mars, no one had ever identified them, in part because orbital images cannot resolve millimeter-scale laminae and in part because no previous rover had driven through sedimentary terrain with both the imaging resolution and the science team bandwidth to spot them.

The Banham paper lays out the diagnostic criteria: millimeter-scale lamina thickness, climb angles between 10 and 18 degrees, preserved stoss-side grainflow cross-stratification, and lateral continuity across the outcrop face. All four appear at Jawbone Canyon. The team estimates that a single 50-millimeter-thick layer could have formed in 6 to 20 minutes under storm conditions; the full succession of six packages therefore records on the order of an hour or two of sustained sand transport (Daily Galaxy, July 17 2026).

Curiosity has been on Mars for more than thirteen years. In that time it has found evidence of ancient lakes, rivers, groundwater, organic molecules, and a past climate that was at least intermittently habitable. What it had not found, until now, is direct evidence of an ancient sandstorm. The Jawbone Canyon outcrop fills that gap with a single rock roughly the size of a kitchen table.

The immediate payoff is a new constraint on early Mars atmospheric density: the air had to be thick enough to drive saltation at storm intensities. The longer-term payoff is a search template. Banham has said the next thing he wants the team to find is raindrop impact marks, craters in fine sediment left by rain, which would settle a separate debate about whether early Mars ever saw liquid rain rather than only snow and surface runoff. “It would be magic if we found those,” he said. The climbing ripples are not the last stop on Curiosity’s geology to-do list. They are evidence that the rover is still, after 4,391 sols, finding things on Mars that no one had asked it to look for.

 

 

NASA illustration of HD 3167 b, a glowing red-orange rocky super-Earth set against a starry background. The planet's dayside surface is rendered as molten silicate, illustrating the lava-world class the new JWST observation now extends to lower irradiation than any previous atmosphere detection.

Image credit: NASA.

 

The James Webb Space Telescope, the NASA/ESA/CSA observatory at the Sun-Earth L2 point, has caught an exoplanet doing something a planet that close to its star really should not be able to do. HD 3167 b is a rocky world roughly one and a half times the size of Earth, and it zips around a K-type star in the constellation Pisces once every 0.96 Earth days. At that distance, the dayside should be glowing red-hot bare rock, the kind of surface where silicates are molten and any gas should have been stripped away by stellar wind and high-energy photons long ago. Instead, the dayside is noticeably cooler than the theoretical maximum, and a new analysis of a JWST secondary eclipse says the most likely reason is an atmosphere. It is the coldest lava world with evidence of an atmosphere on record, and the first result from a survey of ten such worlds led by astronomer Megan Weiner Mansfield. The team’s writeup, as covered by Space.com, lays out what makes the detection hard to explain any other way.

That word cool does not mean comfortable. The planet’s equilibrium temperature sits at about 1786 K, somewhere between a slow oven and molten glass. Lava worlds previously caught with atmospheres have all been hotter than roughly 2200 K. HD 3167 b is hot enough that the rock on its star-facing side is almost certainly molten, and cool enough that something other than bare rock is controlling its dayside temperature.

The result, published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters, comes from a single JWST observation using the Mid-Infrared Instrument’s Low Resolution Spectrometer, the team that has been doing most of the heavy lifting on small rocky exoplanets for the last two years. The team watched HD 3167 b slip behind its host star, a maneuver called a secondary eclipse, and measured how much mid-infrared light disappeared. They measured the white-light eclipse depth at 38 plus or minus 11 parts per million. That number is more than five standard deviations shallower than a dark bare rock with no heat redistribution would produce at this distance from the star. The only good explanations are an atmosphere that reflects some incoming starlight back into space, an atmosphere that moves heat from the day side to the night side, or some combination of the two.

The lead author is Brandon Park Coy, a graduate student at the University of Chicago working in planetary scientist Edwin Kite’s group. Kite is the second author and a co-author on a long line of papers trying to figure out which rocky exoplanets hold onto their air. The HD 3167 b paper, described in a University of Chicago news release, is the first published result of a survey that Megan Weiner Mansfield, who did her PhD at Chicago and is now at the University of Maryland, is running. The program is looking at ten lava worlds with JWST and asking a single question. Below what temperature do rocky planets start losing their atmospheres, and above what temperature do they keep them? The published sample so far suggested a gap. Ultra-hot lava worlds such as 55 Cancri e kept their air. Cooler rocky worlds, the ones too cold to be lava worlds at all, often did not. The boundary lived somewhere in the middle, and nobody had measured it.

HD 3167 b sits right at that boundary. Its dayside is too cool for a bare rock, so it has an atmosphere. Its equilibrium temperature is far below the ultra-hot threshold, so it is the first cool end of the population in question. The boundary should sharpen from a guess into a measured curve as the program keeps adding worlds to the sample.

The detection technique itself is worth slowing down on. A secondary eclipse is the small dip in light that happens when a planet passes behind its star as seen from Earth. The dip is small because the planet is much cooler than the star and emits much less light at the wavelengths being observed, but it is measurable, and the depth of the dip tells you how much of the observed light is the planet’s own thermal emission. Doing this in mid-infrared light, around 15 micrometers for this observation, is what lets JWST see the heat of a planet whose dayside is below 2000 K. The same measurement in visible light would be much less informative, because at those wavelengths the planet contributes essentially nothing.

Why does the dayside being cooler than the maximum matter? On a bare rock world with no atmosphere, the side facing the star absorbs starlight, heats up, and re-radiates that heat as infrared light. The temperature that produces is set by the rock’s reflectivity and the distance to the star, and it is the highest possible dayside temperature for that orbit. Add an atmosphere, and two things change. First, the atmosphere can carry heat from the day side to the night side, evening out the temperature. Second, clouds or hazes can reflect some starlight back into space before it ever reaches the surface, lowering the dayside temperature below the bare-rock maximum. Venus is the textbook example of the first effect, with almost no temperature difference between its equator and poles or between its day and night sides. Earth is the textbook example of the second effect. HD 3167 b is showing one or both on a world whose dayside is liquid rock.

What the atmosphere is actually made of, the team is careful to say, is not known. The single JWST spectrum is not precise enough to pick out individual molecules. The paper notes that the dayside emission spectrum is compatible with a silicate-rich composition consistent with vaporized rock, but also with heavier gases like carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, or water. Picking among those will take follow-up spectroscopy, ideally with JWST’s Near-Infrared Spectrograph, which covers a different wavelength range. The team is also hoping that the rest of the ten-planet program will start to fill in a statistical picture, where several planets measured the same way start to show consistent or inconsistent composition patterns.

The planet itself is also interesting in detail. Its host star, HD 3167, is a K-type main-sequence star slightly smaller and cooler than the Sun, and the planet was first spotted in 2016 in data from the Kepler space telescope’s extended K2 mission, then confirmed by Vanderburg and collaborators in a dedicated follow-up. Like most ultra-short-period rocky worlds, it is tidally locked, with one side permanently facing the star and the other side in permanent night. The new paper refines the planet’s radius to roughly 1.6 Earth radii and confirms the bulk density is slightly lower than a pure Earth-composition planet would suggest, consistent with the planet having a substantial gas layer on top of the rock.

For the broader exoplanet field, the result is a small but real data point in a much larger argument. Most rocky exoplanets found so far, the ones that orbit small cool stars and sit at Earth-like distances, do not have atmospheres. JWST has now measured enough of them to know that, and that has driven a lot of the conversation about whether Earth-like planets are rare or common. Lava worlds are the opposite case. They are easy to observe because they are hot, and the evidence so far is that most of them have something on top of the rock. HD 3167 b extends that trend. It does not change the picture for habitable-zone rocky worlds, but it does sharpen the boundary case where atmospheres start to fail.

There is one quote in the paper and its accompanying press release that captures why a team would spend JWST time on a planet that cannot possibly host life. Lava worlds are useful because they let you watch the processes that matter for all rocky worlds at the extreme end of their temperature range. A planet that is too hot for life can still tell you something about how its rock interacts with its air, how heat moves around, and how clouds form. None of that is unique to lava worlds. All of it shows up in the physics of habitable worlds too. The difference is that on a lava world you can measure it directly, and on a habitable world you mostly have to guess.

 

October 24, 2026

Mega-Earths may be stellar noise

Posted by

 

Planet mass plotted against host stellar activity for 333 small exoplanets, with Mega-Earth candidates as open white circles clustered on the Active and Very Active side and ordinary rocky planets as gray circles spanning the inactive through active range

 

A planet heavier than Neptune but the size of Earth should not, by the rules of how planets form, be a rock. Anything above roughly ten Earth masses is supposed to grab gas from the protoplanetary disk and become a sub-Neptune or larger. Yet a small catalog of worlds has long carried the label “Mega-Earth,” rocky objects sitting above that ten-Earth-mass line, and that label itself colors what people assume about planet formation at the upper end of rocky worlds. A paper published today by Casey Brinkman and Nicolas Cowan at McGill’s Trottier Space Institute argues that the entire category may be a measurement artifact (Brinkman & Cowan 2026, arXiv:2610.12600, reported on by Astrobiology.com the same day). Every candidate Mega-Earth in the literature, the authors show, orbits a magnetically active star. Active starspots and plages mimic and inflate the radial-velocity signal of an orbiting planet, and the chance that all of these outliers would land on active hosts by coincidence is below one percent. The implication is uncomfortable but specific. The Mega-Earths were never there. The detection technique was just seeing starlight flicker, and the label stuck because the underlying objects were just hard enough to disprove.

The category was supposed to mark the upper edge of rocky planet formation. When Xavier Dumusque and colleagues at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics used the HARPS-N spectrograph on La Palma in 2014 to weigh Kepler-10c, the result landed at seventeen Earth masses packed into a radius only 2.35 times Earth’s (Harvard Gazette, June 2014). That density, on the order of seven grams per cubic centimeter, was consistent with a compressed rocky interior under extreme pressure. The team coined the term “Mega-Earth” (Wikipedia: Mega-Earth) on stage at the Boston meeting of the American Astronomical Society, and Dimitar Sasselov called Kepler-10c the “Godzilla of Earths.” The discovery paper was published in The Astrophysical Journal in June 2014. Subsequent surveys added more candidates with apparent masses between ten and forty Earth masses and radii sitting inside the rocky planet regime, and at various points the literature has listed six to eight such worlds, depending on which mass-radius cuts are applied. Each one pressed against a theoretical limit set by collisional mantle stripping and post-formation erosion that no primordial rocky planet should be able to cross.

What jumps out of the resulting scatter plot is that every white-circle Mega-Earth candidate lies on the active side, while the gray-circle population of ordinary rocky and sub-Neptune-mass planets spans inactive through quiet. The four Mega-Earths the authors identify, WASP-84 c, TOI-1347 b, TOI-2322 c, and HD 63433 b, all orbit stars with log R prime HK above negative four point seven five. Three additional planets sit close to the Mega-Earth density regime: GJ 523 b, TOI-815 c, and HD 18599 b. All seven orbit active stars. The probability of that alignment by chance, given how many inactive and quiet-host rocky systems exist in the same sample, comes out below one percent. The authors also note that a previously Mega-Earth-classified world, HD 119130 b, was already re-measured by another group and found to have an inflated mass caused by constructive interference between the planet’s orbital signal and the star’s rotational modulation.

The mechanism behind the contamination is well known but tricky to remove. Starspots and the brighter magnetic regions called plages move across the disk of a rotating star and produce Doppler shifts in the integrated starlight that are indistinguishable, in many pipelines, from the reflex motion of a planet. Starspots suppress local convection and produce false radial-velocity signals at the star’s rotation period. Plages do the same at somewhat different amplitudes. When a planet’s orbital period happens to land near an integer or half-integer multiple of the star’s rotation period, the two signals can constructively interfere and inflate the inferred planet mass by a factor of two or more. That is the situation for several of the candidate Mega-Earth hosts, whose TESS light curves show clean rotational modulation at periods from roughly four to fourteen days. The full radial-velocity datasets that yielded the published masses came from public archives including the NASA Exoplanet Archive, which compiled discovery spectra from HARPS, PFS, and TESS follow-up campaigns. Gaussian-process regression, the tool most often used to handle stellar activity in radial-velocity fits, is only as good as its kernel choices and its priors. When the kernel is too smooth, the process absorbs genuine planetary motion as activity noise. When it is too wiggly, activity noise leaks into the planetary model and inflates the mass.

What the paper does not do is rule out rocky planets above ten Earth masses on theoretical grounds. The runaway gas accretion argument sets ten Earth masses as the threshold above which a core cannot avoid grabbing gas during formation, but it is a threshold, not a wall. Collisional mantle stripping after disk dispersal or photoevaporation of a once-larger planet’s envelope can, in principle, leave a bare rocky remnant. The authors are explicit that those pathways remain possible, just unproven. The Mega-Earth label, in their framing, has been applied to planets whose mass measurements cannot yet distinguish between a real ultra-dense rocky world and a noisy radial-velocity fit around an active star. Re-observing these systems with ESPRESSO on the Very Large Telescope, with HARPS on the TESS-Keck Survey infrastructure, or with NIRPS at La Silla, all of which have the spectral resolution to see activity-induced line-profile variations directly, would settle the question. Several of the candidate Mega-Earths have already been on those queues. The paper, which appeared on the arXiv preprint server on 8 October 2026 and is now in the resubmission cycle for The Astrophysical Journal Letters, lands in a catalog of corrections that have repeatedly eaten specific claimed populations of extreme exoplanets. Stellar contamination has eaten mini-Neptunes hiding inside hot-Jupiter mass measurements, cold Jupiters past ice lines that were artifacts of magnetic cycles, and small-radius planets that turned out to be diluted binaries. Each time, the underlying detection method is sound for inactive host stars and quietly wrong for active ones. Adding Mega-Earths to that list is, in a way, an expected move. The catalog of rocky worlds stays grounded. The Ultra-Massive Rocky Planet threshold, if it exists at all, moves somewhere more difficult to measure from the ground, perhaps requiring JWST transmission spectroscopy of these same systems to constrain atmospheric mass, or years of radial-velocity monitoring as activity cycles rotate through minimum phases. For now the simple chart is enough: a horizontal line at ten Earth masses, with seven suspected outliers sitting on the active side and zero on the quiet side. Pattern recognition cut the question in half.

 

 

Artist's concept of a black hole pulling apart a star, with glowing debris curling into a disk and a bright jet streaming to the right

 

A flare appeared in November 2025 near the outer edge of a galaxy in Cetus. It shone in ultraviolet light with roughly the output of 10 billion Suns and, for a few months, outshone the galaxy itself. That sounds like the sort of event astronomers would notice immediately. The awkward part was its address.

The flare sat more than 30,000 light-years from the galaxy’s center, nowhere near the central supermassive black hole that should have been capable of producing it. Follow-up observations nevertheless showed the signature of a star pulled apart by a massive black hole. The event, named TDE 2025abcr, had exposed an otherwise dark object wandering through the galactic outskirts.

The NASA account of the discovery describes it as the most distant-from-center example of its kind. More important than the record is how it was found: a search deliberately stopped assuming that a galaxy’s biggest black holes must stay in the middle.

Artist’s concept of a tidal disruption event. Credit: NRAO/AUI/NSF/NASA. NASA JPL image page.

Supermassive black holes are usually found through their effects rather than by seeing the objects themselves. At a galaxy’s center, the surrounding stars and gas provide several ways to measure an unseen mass. Far from the nucleus, a quiet black hole can disappear against the sky. It may reveal itself only when matter falls in.

Tidal disruption events offer that brief illumination. NASA estimates that one occurs in a given galaxy about once every 100,000 years, while surveys find roughly 30 across the sky each year. Until recently, optical searches concentrated on galactic nuclei. That was a reasonable filter because known supermassive black holes lived there, but it also built the expected answer into the search.

TDE 2025abcr shows what happens when that positional filter is relaxed. The accepted paper and open preprint calls it the first optical tidal disruption event discovered in the outskirts of a host galaxy. Its inferred black hole mass is about 10^6.09 solar masses, far below the roughly 10^8.82-solar-mass black hole estimated at the host’s center. One galaxy may therefore contain two massive black holes with very different histories and locations.

Finding more such objects would put numbers on a poorly measured population. Wandering black holes preserve evidence of galaxy mergers, stripped dwarf galaxies, and gravitational encounters among black holes. They also test whether catalogs built around bright galactic centers have missed a class of massive objects hiding in plain sight.

The Zwicky Transient Facility, or ZTF, first flagged the brightening in November 2025. ZTF surveys the northern sky from Palomar Observatory and produces an enormous stream of changing points. According to NASA, about half a million flashes are detected each night. A custom version of the machine-learning classifier tdescore examined that stream without requiring candidates to coincide with a galaxy nucleus. It recognized the light curve of TDE 2025abcr even though the source was well off-center.

That initial match was only a prompt for more observing. The galaxy WISEA J014656.04-152214.7 lies about 750 million light-years away. The transient was separated from its nucleus by 9.5 arcseconds, corresponding to a projected distance of 9.3 kiloparsecs. Spectra from ground-based telescopes, including the SOAR telescope in Chile, showed hydrogen and helium emission associated with a tidal disruption event. NASA’s Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory then supplied ultraviolet and X-ray measurements unavailable from the ground. Swift’s ultraviolet telescope measured a temperature near 30,000 degrees Celsius.

Together, the light curve, spectrum, temperature, and location ruled out more ordinary explanations. The researchers classified the source as a hydrogen-and-helium tidal disruption event. Scaling relations between peak luminosity and black hole mass gave an estimate of 10^6.09 solar masses, with an uncertainty of 0.53 dex. That uncertainty is broad, but the result still separates the wandering object from the much heavier black hole expected in the main galaxy’s nucleus.

How did it get there? The team offers two possibilities. In one, several galaxies merged and the interaction among their central black holes ejected the lightest one toward the outskirts. In the other, the black hole remains at the center of a faint dwarf galaxy now being stripped during a minor merger. The dwarf’s stars may be too dim or too dispersed to stand out in current images.

Those explanations can be tested. Deep late-time imaging, after the flare fades, could expose a faint stellar system around the black hole. More off-nuclear events would reveal whether large offsets favor one merger history over another. The paper places the rate of events more than 3 kiloparsecs from a nucleus below 10 percent of the nuclear TDE rate, while predicting that the Vera C. Rubin Observatory could find dozens with resolvable offsets each year.

The timing has an engineering wrinkle. Swift’s pointed observations are temporarily suspended while the mission awaits an orbit boost. Its primary mission ran from 2004 to 2006, yet it has continued watching the changing sky for more than two decades. Rubin can supply a much larger optical sample, and NASA’s Roman telescope can extend the search to greater distances. Swift, once normal operations resume, remains useful for the ultraviolet and X-ray follow-up that turns an unusual point of light into a physical diagnosis.

A tidal disruption begins with a gradient. Gravity is stronger on the side of a star facing a black hole than on the far side. If the star passes close enough, that difference overwhelms the star’s self-gravity. The star stretches, breaks apart, and becomes a stream of gas. As the NASA tidal disruption explainer shows, some debris escapes while some returns, collides, heats up, and gathers around the black hole.

The rough boundary is the tidal radius, often written as r_t approximately equal to R_star times (M_BH/M_star)^(1/3). A larger star is disrupted farther out. A more massive black hole also raises the tidal radius, but only with the cube root of its mass. The event horizon, by contrast, grows directly with black hole mass. This difference explains why a million-solar-mass black hole can tear a Sun-like star apart outside its horizon, where the hot debris remains visible.

The flare is not a photograph of the black hole. It is radiation from gas responding to extreme gravity. Ultraviolet temperature constrains the hot emitting region. Spectral lines identify elements and track changing velocities. X-rays probe hotter material closer to the compact object. None of these measurements alone settles the case; their agreement does.

The classifier solves a different problem. A survey camera records real transients alongside variable stars, supernovae, moving objects, and instrumental artifacts. A model trained on known tidal disruption light curves can rank candidates, but a model trained only on nuclear examples may learn location as a shortcut. The off-nuclear version of tdescore removed that shortcut. Its success is a clean lesson in survey design: changing a selection rule can reveal objects the telescope had already become capable of seeing.

TDE 2025abcr did not make a wandering black hole appear. It made one observable for a few months. A star supplied the fuel, ZTF caught the changing light, and Swift helped establish what produced it. The result is a black hole of roughly a million solar masses projected 9.3 kiloparsecs from the center of a massive galaxy.

The remaining question is whether this object was kicked out of a galactic nucleus or still occupies the fading core of a stripped dwarf. Late-time imaging may answer that for this system. Rubin’s larger alert stream can answer the population question by finding enough examples to compare.

The useful change was modest: researchers searched outside the place where theory and habit told them to look. If Rubin finds the predicted dozens of resolvable off-center events each year, TDE 2025abcr will become less of an oddity and more of a map marker for a hidden population moving through galactic outskirts.