OrbitalHub

Where curiosity reaches escape velocity.

Domain is for sale. $50,000,000.00 USD. Direct any inquiries to contact@orbitalhub.com.

 

NASA's Artemis III operations concept graphic showing New Glenn launching the Blue Moon Mark 2 lander test article, the Space Launch System launching from pad 39B, and Starship launching a lander test article from pad 39A, with the sequence of Orion docking checks through splashdown in low Earth orbit.

 

Getting American astronauts back to the lunar surface now depends on three rockets that mostly do not look alike, and on the fact that all three are changing at once. On 23 October 2026, at a press conference at Kennedy Space Center, NASA laid out how Artemis III will be flown, and the answer was a rehearsal, not a landing. Four astronauts will launch on the Space Launch System in 2027, dock with a test Blue Moon lander and a test Starship in Earth orbit, and come home. The landing itself moves to Artemis IV in 2028, and the first crew on the surface since Apollo 17 will ride on whichever of the two commercial landers proves ready first (NASA’s release on the revised plan).

That rework set off a hardware sprint across three launch pads. Each vehicle is getting a new upper stage, a new engine, or a whole new configuration, and the changes are not interchangeable. SLS is losing the upgrade it was supposed to get and gaining a different one. Starship is getting a docking adapter, a tanker fleet and an upper stage for its own lander. New Glenn is getting a bigger first stage, a rebuilt pad and a four-launch plan that was not in the original design. Side by side, the three are three answers to one question: how do you get a crew to the Moon and back without flying the same hardware twice?

The reordering also exposes an uncomfortable schedule. NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman announced the new sequence roughly a month before Artemis II lifted off in April 2026, and officials now describe Artemis III as an Earth-orbit test in mid-2027, with Artemis IV and Artemis V both aimed at landings in 2028 (SpacePolicyOnline on the schedule). The South Pole remains the destination, justified by water ice thought to be accessible in permanently shadowed terrain, though the agency concedes it needs more data from robotic landers before committing. The suits are being built by Axiom Space. One detail is significant: the docking test happens in low Earth orbit rather than near the Moon, letting NASA learn the hard parts of rendezvous while a crew is still a quick flight from the splashdown.

The Space Launch System is the odd one out, the only one of the three being simplified. NASA’s original plan was a Block 1 rocket with the Interim Cryogenic Propulsion Stage for the first missions, then a Block 1B with Boeing’s larger Exploration Upper Stage and a Block 2 with new solid boosters. That ladder was dropped in February 2026; the agency settled on a standardized configuration and picked ULA’s Centaur V as the upper stage to replace the interim stage from Artemis IV onward (Space.com on the upper-stage selection). Centaur V has flown on Vulcan since 2024 and holds roughly twice the propellant of the interim stage, and NASA is working with ULA on an extended version for the low-lunar-orbit role the new architecture calls for (Ars Technica on the revised architectures). For Artemis III itself, SLS will fly without a propulsion stage at all, using a non-propulsive spacer instead, since the mission never leaves Earth orbit.

Starship’s contribution to the same plan is the most expensive one, and the most contested. Under the revised concept, tanker variants of Starship fill a depot ship in low Earth orbit, the lander and Orion dock there, and the lander performs the burn that sends the combined stack toward the Moon (NASA’s release on the revised plan). How many tankers that takes is the argument. At a NASA Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel meeting, panel member and former astronaut Charlie Precourt put the estimate at around 22 flights, noting the large number of firsts stacked against Artemis IV. Elon Musk responded that the real figure would be closer to six to eight (Ars Technica on the tanker estimate). The gap is not just numerical. It depends on how much cryogenic methane and liquid oxygen boil off in orbit and how efficiently the transfer works, neither yet demonstrated. Even at a twice-weekly launch rate by the end of 2027, Ars Technica’s analysis puts the time to fuel a single depot at roughly three months.

New Glenn is the third rocket, and it is carrying the most physical damage. On 28 May 2026, a static fire at Cape Canaveral destroyed a fully stacked New Glenn and much of Launch Complex 36. Blue Origin traced the anomaly to the main liquid oxygen valve on one of the seven BE-4 engines in the first stage, with the root cause still open at the time of reporting, and began rebuilding the pad in June with a public target of returning to flight before the end of 2026 (KeepTrack on the LC-36 explosion and recovery). The rebuilt pad, LC-36A, flies the current 7×2 configuration, while LC-36B is being built for the heavier 9×4. New Glenn has flown three times, its third on 19 April 2026 ending with the loss of the payload, and its November 2025 ESCAPADE booster reused on that attempt. All of that sits underneath a lander campaign that needs the rocket to fly four times.

The engineering behind the new variants is where the three programs diverge most sharply. New Glenn 9×4 replaces the current 7×2 with nine BE-4 engines on the first stage and four BE-3Us on the upper stage, carries a fairing widened from 7 metres to 8.7 metres, and lifts roughly 70 metric tons to low Earth orbit against 45 tons for the original configuration, with the engine upgrades phased in starting with the third mission (Space.com on the 9×4 variant). Starship’s lunar lander and its depot ship shed hardware rather than adding it: neither re-enters Earth’s atmosphere, so both drop the heat shield and the fins, and the lander keeps six Raptor engines for ascent and landing while separate high-thrust engines in the mid-body burn gaseous oxygen and methane to avoid blasting the regolith (Wikipedia on the Starship HLS vehicle family). Blue Moon takes the opposite approach, keeping liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen with a solar-powered system that holds propellant near 20 kelvin to fight boiloff, which matters for a lander meant to sit on the Moon rather than leave (Wikipedia on the Blue Moon lander family). And beneath all of it, the crew rocket changes hands: from Artemis V, NASA plans to transfer SLS production and launch operations to Deep Space Transport LLC, a Boeing and Northrop Grumman joint venture, hoping commercial customers spread the cost (Wikipedia on Deep Space Transport LLC).

The three vehicles have also started flying. Starship reached orbit for the first time on 28 September 2026 on flight test 14, deploying 26 operational Starlink V3 satellites after one of the six second-stage engines shut down early, which cut the planned six-orbit profile short but not the orbit itself (SpacePolicyOnline on the first orbital flight). For Artemis III, the sequence runs to a 14-day nominal mission: New Glenn goes first with the Blue Moon test article, SLS launches the crew next, and Starship flies on about flight day six to dock on day eight, with the Blue Moon docking on day three at roughly 273 miles (Space.com on the concept of operations).

What ties the three together is the 2028 landing, and what separates them is how each program pays for it. Blue Origin chose the conservative route, deferring in-orbit propellant transfer and instead flying three transfer stages built from existing Mark 1 and Mark 2 hardware ahead of the Blue Moon Mark 2 Alpha lander, which assembles in Earth orbit and departs for an elliptical polar orbit around the Moon. That is four New Glenn launches with no spacecraft-to-spacecraft refueling, on a booster whose pad was vaporized in May. SpaceX chose the opposite, betting that orbital refueling works well enough that a handful of tanker flights will cover the lander, a bet its own safety advisory board thinks is off by more than a factor of three. NASA bought optionality by choosing neither, flying both dockings in Earth orbit in 2027 and deciding the landing provider from what the data shows. The next real milestone is not a landing but a docking, and the hardware that has to make it work is still in pads and test stands.

NASA’s Artemis III operations concept graphic, showing the three launch vehicles and the docking sequence in low Earth orbit.

 

 

The X-37B spaceplane sits on the runway at Vandenberg Space Force Base after landing from its seventh mission in March 2025, the American vehicle whose design the Chinese Shenlong closely resembles (U.S. Space Force/Alexander Veloz via Wikimedia Commons)

 

Some photographs carry more information than their subjects were ever meant to give up. On 26 October the Defense Intelligence Agency released the third edition of its unclassified survey of threats in space (The Defense Watch on the DIA 2026 report), and on page 53 of the 130-page document sits a picture of a Chinese spaceplane in orbit that nobody outside a small circle of intelligence analysts had seen at full resolution (DIA press release for the 2026 edition). The shot was taken by a commercial Earth observation satellite, a WorldView-3 operated by Maxar Technologies, the company now known as Vantor, on 28 May 2024 while the craft was on the long middle leg of its third flight (Wikipedia on the Chinese reusable experimental spacecraft mission history). What the image gives up is the vehicle’s shape: a delta-winged body, doors along the flank for a payload bay, a dark heat shield across the belly, and a service module at the rear with solar arrays on short outriggers (Ars Technica on the Shenlong photograph).

That photo was not a leak and it was not a spy agency going public with something it had been sitting on. In 2024 a US Space Force officer disclosed at a conference in South Korea that an American-owned commercial satellite had imaged the Chinese craft, and a lower resolution version of the picture circulated afterwards (Wikipedia on the Chinese reusable experimental spacecraft mission history). The agency has now released the whole thing, credited to Maxar, inside a document whose stated purpose is to inform public debate rather than to leak anything (DIA press release for the 2026 edition). There is an argument that publishing it makes the vehicle more useful to adversaries than it already was. There is also an argument that a program developed in near total silence is a program nobody can write norms around, and that the public photograph is the first step toward treating it as an ordinary vehicle rather than a rumour.

What the image shows is a machine built along the lines of the X-37B, the uncrewed spaceplane the US Space Force flies, and the resemblance runs deeper than the outline. The American vehicle lifts off vertically inside a conventional rocket’s payload shroud, works as a satellite once in orbit, then reentres and lands by itself on a runway to be refurbished for another flight (Ars Technica on the Shenlong photograph). The Chinese craft does the same, on a Long March 2F from Jiuquan, landing back at an airbase in the Gobi. The difference is what the vehicle is for, and that is where the language gets careful. The report’s own framing is that spaceplanes are reusable and have enhanced maneuverability, which makes them more suitable for certain missions than ordinary satellites, and it names two Chinese programs, Shenlong and Tengyun (Ars Technica on the Shenlong photograph). A separate Secure World Foundation fact sheet is blunter about the limits of the alarm, concluding that the vehicle has close to zero feasibility as an orbital weapon for striking ground targets and has never approached a non-Chinese object, which reads as a technology demonstrator rather than a warhead (Secure World Foundation fact sheet).

The flight record is what makes the picture interesting rather than merely striking. The first prototype went up in September 2020 and came back down two days later. The second flight launched in August 2022 and stayed up for 276 days, and during that mission it moved around a small companion satellite, holding roughly a kilometre of separation and at one point coming within about 100 metres of it, which observers read as a rendezvous before the smaller object was released again. The third flight, launched in December 2023 and still up when the Maxar camera caught it, lasted the better part of nine months and involved the spaceplane releasing and then interacting with another object. A fourth mission launched from Jiuquan on 7 February 2026 and was still in orbit when the report came out (Leonard David on the DIA report’s spaceplane flight history). By the end of that third flight the vehicle had logged a cumulative year and a half in orbit, and it was manoeuvring around objects it had deployed itself rather than flying a solo mission, which is the difference between a test article and a working spacecraft (Wikipedia on the Chinese reusable experimental spacecraft mission history).

The technique behind the picture deserves more attention than it gets. The field has a name, non-Earth imaging, and it works because the geometry occasionally lines up: an Earth observation satellite pointed at a piece of ground passes close enough to another spacecraft to photograph it as it goes by, at relative speeds measured in kilometres per second (Ars Technica on the Shenlong photograph). Commercial operators such as Maxar have turned that into a service, and government analysts buy it. The cost of the observation is the orbital mechanics of the chance encounter, not a dedicated spy platform, which is why a picture of a classified Chinese vehicle exists at all. For comparison, the X-37B has a published specification that no one outside the Space Force could match: more than 29 feet long, a wingspan near 15 feet, and orbital speed of roughly 17,400 mph (Popular Science on the DIA spaceplane photograph). The Shenlong’s dimensions remain unpublished, and the vehicle’s actual payload is classified on both sides.

The larger document puts the spaceplane in a wider argument about where the competition is heading. China’s launch cadence has gone from 22 launches in 2016 to 93 in 2025, and the number of satellites it puts into orbit each year has grown from 40 to 384 over the same period, a rate increase running alongside the national LEO megaconstellations Beijing is building (The Defense Watch on the DIA 2026 report). Alongside the reusable spaceplane work sits a much more explicitly aggressive portfolio: satellites with robotic arms, a demonstration of moving a dead navigation satellite into a graveyard orbit, a test of refuelling in geostationary orbit, and a series of inspector craft that have closed to within ten kilometres of other nations’ spacecraft in that orbit (The Defense Watch on the DIA 2026 report). The report’s sharpest new judgment is on directed energy: China already fields several ground-based laser systems of varying power that can disrupt, degrade or damage satellites in low Earth orbit, and by the late 2020s may field space-based directed energy systems along with more powerful ground systems able to threaten satellites in higher orbits (The Defense Watch on the DIA 2026 report). It is a projection, stated as a possibility, and the underlying intelligence is not published.

None of that changes the photograph. What the public now has is a clear look at a vehicle that has flown four times, spent 276 days on its longest completed mission so far, and demonstrated close approach manoeuvres with its own deployed satellites, while the X-37B on the American side has flown eight times and at one point extended a record of 908 days in orbit (Wikipedia on the X-37B flight record). What the reader does not have is a mission statement from Beijing, a set of dimensions for the Chinese craft, or confirmation of what the fourth mission is doing right now. The next useful pieces of information would be a landing date for the flight launched in February, the next edition of this assessment, and any Chinese statement of purpose for a program that has now been photographed in public twice.

 

 

Artist's impression of a futuristic city on Mars under a vast geodesic glass dome, its tower blocks rising among forests and lakes, with smaller domes spread across the Martian terrain beyond (DALL-E 3, via Wikimedia Commons)

 

Abstract

This post explores what happens to proof-of-work cryptocurrency protocols once the network stretches across the solar system and beyond. Cryptocurrencies are here to stay, and it is plausible that future colonists will prefer a decentralized currency over a fiat currency issued by a distant central authority. Ubiquitous access, independence from exchange-rate and interest-rate policy set on another planet, and freedom from financial institutions serving foreign interests are strong arguments in an emerging exo-economy.

It is tempting to assume that relativistic time dilation would be the main threat to an interplanetary proof-of-work network. Running the numbers says otherwise: inside the solar system, time dilation is a rounding error, and the real enemy is the finite speed of light. This post works through both effects and sketches designs that could hold up.

Motivation

Today, information broadcast by a node reaches nearly every other node within a few seconds. The Internet spans the Earth’s surface and low Earth orbit, so the worst-case path is a fraction of a light-second long.

That stops being true the moment the network leaves Earth’s neighborhood. Approximate one-way light delays:

Link, One-way delay
Earth to LEO satellite: a few milliseconds
Earth to Moon: about 1.3 seconds
Earth to Mars: about 3 to 22 minutes, depending on orbital positions
Earth to Jupiter: about 33 to 53 minutes
Earth to TRAPPIST-1: about 40 years

Once delays approach the block interval, the network starts to suffer: more communication failures, more frequent and longer blockchain forks, and eventually segregation into local sub-networks (let us call them topological forks). For deep-space links, the plumbing is not TCP/IP either. NASA and others use Delay/Disruption-Tolerant Networking (the Bundle Protocol), which stores and forwards data across links that are slow and intermittently available.

Nullius in verba, as they say. Let’s go into the details and figure out what a truly interplanetary cryptocurrency would need.

Cryptocurrency 101

Think of a cryptocurrency as a digital money ecosystem. It combines decades of research in cryptography and distributed systems: a decentralized network of computers, a public transaction ledger (the blockchain), a set of transaction validation rules, and a decentralized consensus mechanism [ANTO].

The network. Computing power and data are spread across many nodes. Every full node keeps a copy of the ledger, so the network survives disruption, including physical damage to individual nodes.

The blockchain. A public, distributed ledger of every transaction the network has accepted. Each block holds as many transactions as fit within the network’s block size or weight limit. Transactions name the sender, the receiver and the amount or asset changing hands. Each block contains the cryptographic hash of the previous one, a backward link that runs all the way to the chain’s Genesis block. Tampering with any old block changes its hash and breaks every link after it.

Validation rules. Every node checks every transaction. The most common fraud attempt is double spending, so nodes verify that each transaction’s inputs exist and have not already been spent. Invalid transactions are rejected and never reach the chain.

Consensus. The consensus mechanism lets all nodes agree on which transactions go into the next block. It replaces the authority of a central clearing house with a network of nodes that do not trust each other, and do not need to, because the protocol enforces the trust.

The Proof-of-Work

Satoshi Nakamoto proposed proof-of-work consensus in 2008 [NAKA]. A proof-of-work is a piece of data that is costly and slow to produce but trivial to verify. Think of a semester project: it takes you a whole semester to finish, and your supervisor an hour to grade.

To add a block, a miner must find a nonce that makes the block’s hash fall below a target. The only way to find one is brute-force guessing, so a miner’s chance of winning the next block is proportional to its share of the network’s total hash rate. The network retunes the target so that blocks arrive at a fixed average interval. For Bitcoin that is 10 minutes, with difficulty recalculated every 2,016 blocks (about two weeks).

When two miners find blocks at nearly the same moment, the chain forks briefly. Nodes resolve it by following the chain with the most accumulated work. This is how Nakamoto consensus reaches agreement without a trusted authority.

Then and now. For years, proof-of-work was the de facto consensus mechanism. That is no longer true. Ethereum switched to proof-of-stake in September 2022 (“the Merge”), and most newer networks use proof-of-stake or other Byzantine-fault-tolerant designs. Bitcoin, the largest network by value, remains proof-of-work, and it is the reference case for the rest of this post.

Why latency breaks it. The longest-chain rule quietly assumes that a new block reaches everyone much faster than the block interval. If a block takes d seconds to reach the bulk of the hash rate, and blocks arrive every T seconds on average, the chance that a competing block appears in the meantime is roughly:

$$
P_{text{stale}} approx 1 – e^{-d/T}
$$

On Earth, d is a few seconds and T is 600 seconds, so stale blocks are rare. For a miner on Mars, d is 3 to 22 minutes, giving a stale probability of roughly 26% to 89%. Mars miners would also spend those minutes hashing on top of a block that Earth has already buried. Their effective reward collapses, they have no reason to stay honest participants, and the network segregates. That is the topological fork from the motivation, and it happens long before relativity enters the picture.

Enter the Ansible

We have no technology that communicates quickly and reliably across interplanetary, let alone interstellar, distances. Consider a mining corporation in the TRAPPIST-1 system, about 40 light-years away in the constellation Aquarius, paying a planetary engineering firm in the Sol system. The payment would take about 81 years for the round trip, plus the block confirmation time.

Science fiction already offers a fix. Readers of Rocannon’s World [LEGU], where Ursula K. Le Guin coined the word in 1966, and of Ender’s Game [CARD] will know the ansible: a device that sends and receives messages over any distance with no delay.

One honest caveat before we lean on it. Special relativity says there is no universal “now”. Two events that are simultaneous for one observer are not simultaneous for another moving relative to the first. An instantaneous link is therefore instantaneous only in some chosen frame, and combining such links with moving observers can deliver a message before it was sent. The ansible is not just beyond our engineering; it is in tension with the physics the rest of this post relies on. We will use it anyway, because it isolates a cleaner question: if latency vanished, would relativity still hurt proof-of-work?

The Special Theory of Relativity

Before upgrading the protocol, we need the physics of how time and distance depend on the observer’s frame of reference.

Einstein received the 1921 Nobel Prize in Physics, awarded in 1922, “for his services to Theoretical Physics, and especially for his discovery of the law of the photoelectric effect.” Relativity was famous by then but still controversial, and the committee chose not to cite it.

Einstein set out to reconcile two principles: the principle of relativity, and the constancy of the speed of light. His well-known thought experiment uses a train [EINS]. A passenger walks toward the front at speed w relative to the train, while the train moves at speed v relative to the embankment. Classical mechanics says an observer on the embankment measures the passenger’s speed as W = v + w. Replace the passenger with a beam of light and the same rule gives v + c, contradicting the principle that light travels at c in every inertial frame. Einstein resolved the contradiction by giving up absolute time.

The Lorentz transformation. Before relativity, time was absolute, independent of the observer’s motion. After it, every inertial frame has its own time, and a statement about time must say which frame it refers to. Requiring that light moves at c in every inertial frame leads to the Lorentz transformation between a frame K and a frame K′ moving at velocity v along the x axis:

$$
x’ = gamma,(x – v t), quad y’ = y, quad z’ = z, quad t’ = gammaleft(t – frac{v x}{c^{2}}right), qquad gamma = frac{1}{sqrt{1 – v^{2}/c^{2}}}
$$

Here γ is the Lorentz factor. Letting c go to infinity makes γ equal 1 and recovers the Galilean transformation of classical mechanics (x′ = x − vt, t′ = t), where both distance and time are absolute.

Time dilation. The corollary that matters here: a clock moving at speed v relative to an observer runs slow as measured by that observer. If Δτ is the interval between two ticks in the clock’s own rest frame (its proper time), the observer measures:

$$
Delta t = gamma,Deltatau
$$

Since γ ≥ 1, the observer always measures the longer interval.

Real frames are not inertial. A clock on Earth’s surface rides a rotating planet orbiting the Sun, so strictly it is not in an inertial frame. For most purposes the approximation works, but precise timekeeping must also account for gravity. General relativity adds gravitational time dilation: clocks deeper in a gravitational well tick slower. GPS is the everyday proof [ASHB]. Satellite clocks run about 7 microseconds per day slow because of their orbital speed, and about 45 microseconds per day fast because they sit higher in Earth’s gravity well. Without the net correction of roughly 38 microseconds per day, GPS positions would drift by kilometers within a day.

Relativistic Effects on Proof-of-Work

The twin paradox is the classic illustration of time dilation. One twin travels on a relativistic spaceship and returns home to find the other twin has aged far more. Fly fast enough or long enough, and several generations pass on Earth during the trip. Orson Scott Card used exactly this in Ender’s Game [CARD]: Mazer Rackham, the pilot who ended the Second Formic Invasion, is sent on a relativistic round trip so that, decades later, he can train the next commander while having aged only a few years.

Now put a mining sub-network on a fast-moving ship, connected to the rest of the network by an ansible. Measured in Earth’s frame, the ship’s hardware runs slow by the factor γ, so it computes fewer hashes per Earth-second.

The tempting fix. One could treat this as a fairness problem: lower the proof-of-work difficulty on the ship by the Lorentz factor, so relativistic miners solve an easier puzzle, and shorten their block confirmation time.

Why that does not work. Proof-of-work is not a race against the clock; it is a measure of computation. Chain weight is accumulated work, and the protocol never asks how long a miner took. A time-dilated miner is, to everyone else, simply a slower machine, exactly like an older ASIC on Earth. Bitcoin does not lower difficulty for slow hardware, and it should not lower it for fast-moving hardware either. A lower difficulty on the ship means cheaper blocks, which means either the ship’s blocks count for less chain weight (so the discount cancels out) or they count the same (so the ship can out-produce Earth at a fraction of the cost). Worse, the discount is triggered by a claim that nobody else can verify: any node that can fake a slower beacon gets cheaper blocks. Fairness in proof-of-work is measured in hashes, and the network should keep a single global difficulty.

How big is the effect, anyway? For realistic solar-system traffic, it is negligible:

Scenario, Clock rate difference vs Earth, Effect on hash rate
Mars miner (orbital speeds up to tens of km/s, plus gravity difference): on the order of 1 part in 100 million: about a millisecond per day
Ship at 0.5c: γ ≈ 1.15: about 13% fewer hashes per Earth-second
Ship at 0.87c: γ ≈ 2: half the hashes per Earth-second

Compare the first row with the 26% to 89% stale-block penalty that light delay imposes on the same Mars miner. Inside the solar system, latency is the whole problem and relativity is a footnote. Relativity only matters for ships moving at a large fraction of c, and even there the right response is to accept the lower effective hash rate, not to discount the difficulty.

Where clocks do matter: timestamps. Proof-of-work protocols do care about clocks in one place. Block timestamps must fall within a tolerance of network time, and difficulty retargeting is computed from them. A node whose local clock is dilated, or sits in a different gravity well, will drift away from everyone else’s notion of time. The fix is the one astronomers already use: define a single coordinate time for the network (for the solar system, something like Barycentric Coordinate Time, TCB) and have every node convert its local clock to it. A simple beacon does the job. If an Earth-side ansible broadcasts a tick every fixed interval of network time, a node that counts its own seconds between ticks learns its clock rate relative to the network and can correct its timestamps. (With ordinary light-speed beacons instead of an ansible, the measured interval would be dominated by the Doppler shift from the node’s motion, not by γ alone, and would need to be separated out.)

A More Down-to-Earth Solution

Let’s fork the storyline (pun intended) back at Enter the Ansible and drop the faster-than-light link. Light delay is now the constraint, and there are several ways to live with it.

1. Peripheral nodes relay, Earth mines. Mining stays on and around Earth, and nodes on Mars or elsewhere only relay transactions and verify blocks. A Martian payment confirms after roughly twice the one-way light delay plus the confirmation time: on the order of an hour or more. Its weakness is an eclipse attack. A local miner can feed Martian nodes a fabricated chain until the real one arrives minutes later. Martian merchants therefore cannot trust anything that has not been confirmed by blocks that demonstrably came from Earth’s hash rate, so local commerce waits on interplanetary round trips.

2. One currency, local settlement layers. Keep a single base chain for interplanetary settlement, and run fast local systems on each world: a Mars-side payment channel network, a sidechain, or a rollup that periodically anchors its state to the base chain. Everyday payments on Mars clear in seconds; only the net balances cross the gap. The catch is that today’s channel designs rely on time-locked dispute windows, which would need to be far longer than any interplanetary round trip.

3. Separate local chains, trustless exchange. Each world runs its own chain, with a block interval and consensus tuned to its own network. Value moves between them through atomic swaps or bridges. This accepts the topological fork as a feature rather than fighting it. It mirrors how separate economies already trade, but bridges have been among the most frequently exploited components in crypto, so this layer needs the most scrutiny.

4. Consensus with finality. Proof-of-stake and other Byzantine-fault-tolerant protocols finalize blocks once a supermajority of validators agrees. They avoid probabilistic forks, but each round of voting is bounded by the slowest validator, so an interplanetary validator set would finalize at the pace of light delay. A local validator set per world, with periodic cross-world checkpoints, is the more practical variant.

Whichever design wins, one incentive rule still holds: for every node, the reward for staying honest on the shared network must outweigh anything it could gain by cheating locally.

Concluding Remarks

The ansible is fiction; the rest is not. Running the numbers gives a clear answer: inside the solar system, the speed of light breaks proof-of-work long before time dilation does. Relativity’s real lesson for an interplanetary protocol is about clocks, not difficulty: pick one coordinate time and convert everything to it.

Thank you for working through this exercise with us. Cryptocurrencies have kept reshaping finance in recent years, and as a species we will go far beyond low Earth orbit. History suggests that decentralization is key to resilience and prosperity. The protocols that follow us out there will have to be designed for the delays of space from day one. Let us make that future happen together.

Image: A futuristic city on Mars, built under a vast geodesic glass dome around lakes and parks, with tower blocks at its centre and smaller domes scattered across the red terrain beyond. Credit: DALL-E 3, released into the public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

References

• [ANTO] Antonopoulos, Andreas M., Mastering Bitcoin, Second Edition, O’Reilly Media, 2017.
• [ASHB] Ashby, Neil, “Relativity in the Global Positioning System,” Living Reviews in Relativity 6, 2003.
• [CARD] Card, Orson Scott, Ender’s Game, Tor Teen, 2014 (first published 1985).
• [EINS] Einstein, Albert, Relativity: The Special and the General Theory, Princeton University Press, 2015.
• [LEGU] Le Guin, Ursula K., Rocannon’s World, Harper & Row, 1977 (first published 1966).
• [NAKA] Nakamoto, Satoshi, Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, 2008.

 

 

The fault under Valles Marineris is still slipping. Image: 2026 10 21 valles marineris marsquake.

 

Valles Marineris runs nearly 3,900 kilometres across Mars, reaches 600 kilometres wide in places, and drops more than nine kilometres from rim to floor. NASA calls it the largest canyon system in the solar system, and by the numbers it is not a close call: nearly nine times longer than the Grand Canyon, more than twenty times wider, roughly five times deeper (NASA, NASA Science). For most of the last two decades it has been treated as scenery, a feature that formed in the first billion years of Martian history and has been sitting quietly ever since. A paper published in Nature Communications on 15 October makes that assumption harder to hold. Jung-Hun Song of Imperial College London and colleagues report direct seismic evidence that the ground deep beneath the canyon is still moving, and that the structure controlling where it moves was inherited from the canyon’s own formation billions of years ago (Nature Communications).

The evidence comes from a single earthquake. On sol 976 of the InSight mission, 25 August 2021, the lander recorded an event its catalogue calls S0976a. It was unusual in two ways that made it useful. It arrived from the far side of the planet, roughly 146 degrees away, more than any other well-located marsquake InSight had found, and it was the only event in the mission’s catalogue that could be pinned to Mars’s western hemisphere. It was also puzzling. A seismic signal on Mars does not automatically mean a fault broke. Meteoroid impacts, landslides, and mass wasting all send vibrations through the crust, and the earlier analysis of S0976a had placed it near western Valles Marineris without settling on a cause. Nobody had shown that it was a marsquake at all, rather than something falling over.

Song’s team went back to the raw seismograms and asked what kind of motion would produce that signature. The answer turned on a problem of geometry. Working out how a fault ruptured normally requires many seismometers spread around the source, sampling the radiation pattern from many directions. InSight was one station, sitting roughly 8,000 kilometres away on the opposite side of Mars, so it sampled the pattern once, badly. The trick the team used is that seismic waves bouncing off the planet’s surface arrive as echoes, and each echo corresponds to a different angle between the wave and the surface it left. By jointly inverting the first-arriving P and S echoes, called PP and SS, the team recovered the fault geometry from a single station, validated first against a terrestrial event recorded the same way.

The solution is a predominantly double-couple strike-slip mechanism: blocks of crust sliding horizontally past each other on a steep fault. Across the acceptable solutions, 82.2 percent fall in the strike-slip family, with nodal plane strikes clustering around 48 and 143 degrees and dips steep enough to be nearly vertical. The best-fitting mechanism gives fault strikes near 60 and 330 degrees. The pressure axis sits roughly parallel to the canyon trough, the tension axis roughly perpendicular to it, which reads as horizontal extension across the canyon combined with shear along its length. Depth is the other half of the answer. The source lies in the middle to lower crust, above a Moho estimated at 55 to 65 kilometres beneath western Valles Marineris, with the allowed depth range running from about 20 to 40 kilometres depending on which interior velocity model is used. That is intact crust, not the loose material at the surface.

Rejecting the alternatives took as much work as finding the mechanism. The team ran impact-like explosions, single-force landslide models, and combinations of double-couple and non-double-couple sources, comparing each against the observed waveforms. None of the impact or landslide models reproduced the PP and SS arrivals. A landslide of the size needed to generate an event this big on Mars would have required a failure volume of at least 10 million cubic metres, which should have left a fresh deposit hundreds of metres to a kilometre across. The team checked every available post-event Context Camera image from the source region and found no fresh crater and no new collapse. The seismic data and the orbital imagery pointed the same way, which is what makes the result convincing rather than merely interesting: two kinds of evidence converging on one answer.

The geology says something the seismology alone cannot. Western Valles Marineris is crisscrossed by long-lived fault systems, and the stress orientation from the focal mechanism matches what those structures would experience today. Song’s team mapped faults, grabens, wrinkle ridges, and boulder-fall sites from high-resolution imagery and found a bimodal population of grabens with dominant strikes near 15 and 115 degrees, defining an orthogonal fault set. The P and T axes from the earthquake line up with those dominant trends. The best interpretation is slip on inherited fabric, not the creation of something new: the fault that broke in 2021 was already there, and the present-day stress field is now favourable for it to slip again.

What supplies that stress is a more open question, and the honest answer is a combination. Three sources are invoked. Long-term planetary cooling supplies a background horizontal compression, which no amount of waiting makes go away. Tharsis, the enormous volcanic rise west of the canyon, loads the lithosphere and flexes it, modifying both the magnitude and the orientation of the horizontal principal stresses. And the canyon itself, having been deeply incised, has unloaded the crust vertically, which reduces vertical stress and produces horizontal compression. At the source depth the basaltic crust carries lithostatic pressures of several hundred megapascals, a confining pressure that suppresses tensile opening and favours brittle shear failure instead. The paper is explicit that the relative contributions of flexural loading and dynamic support cannot be separated uniquely from this event alone.

Two results change what the data means beyond this canyon. The first is the aftershock question, and the answer is that InSight would not have seen one. The authors modelled aftershock production and wave propagation and found that ground displacements from a marsquake in western Valles Marineris would rarely exceed the ambient noise level at the lander, a consequence of geometric limits on long-distance propagation across Mars, including core shadowing. The probability of detecting even a single sizeable aftershock within 50 sols is 0.1 percent, which is a strange thing to have calculated, and I am glad they ran the numbers. The absence of follow-up events in the catalogue therefore says nothing about whether the fault is quiet, which is a limit of the instrument rather than of the planet. The second is the comparison across three regions. InSight’s seismograms now resolve three distinct styles of present-day deformation on Mars: strike-slip faulting beneath Valles Marineris from S0976a, compressional faulting in southern Elysium Planitia from S1222a, and normal faulting beneath Cerberus Fossae. Three different mechanisms in three different places means deformation is partitioned across a mechanically heterogeneous shell rather than driven by one planet-wide stress pattern.

The broader implication is about stagnant-lid planets, which is most rocky worlds. Mars has no plate tectonics; its outer shell behaves more like a single lid that cools slowly rather than recycling. Whether faults formed early in a planet’s history can stay weak enough to matter billions of years later has been argued about theoretically and never directly confirmed, because the geological record alone cannot distinguish a fault that reactivated today from one that has been dead since the Hesperian. A dated, located seismic event with a fault mechanism is exactly the missing measurement. Fault zones in a stagnant lid heal slowly, and stress fields evolve slowly, so the two together can keep old structures marginally close to failure indefinitely. The motion at the bottom of Valles Marineris is happening on the same fault that was already there when the canyon opened, under a stress field that has drifted slowly since.

Song put it plainly: “faults deep beneath the canyon can still slip and generate marsquakes” (Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia Climate School). The InSight mission ended in 2022 and its seismometer is off, but the recordings it returned are still producing results five years on. This one is the clearest evidence yet that a planet’s oldest fractures are still part of its present.

 

 

Patrick Stewart speaking at the 2019 San Diego Comic-Con International, wearing a dark jacket over an open-collared white shirt with a yellow and black backdrop behind him (Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons)

 

The day the captain left the bridge

I heard the news today, and I’m still sitting with it. Sir Patrick Stewart has died at 86. To the world he was many things: a Shakespearean actor, a knight, Professor X. To me, he will always be Captain Jean-Luc Picard first.

I first met him on the bridge of the USS Enterprise. I was 14 when I first watched The Next Generation. He didn’t swagger the way TV heroes usually did. He sat down, tugged his uniform straight, listened to his crew, and then made a decision.

Something about that calm made the stars feel reachable. Picard is the reason I started reading about real space exploration: rockets, orbits, probes, the people who actually build the ships. I know I’m not the only one. Today is a loss for a whole generation who looked up because a quiet man in a red uniform told us there was something worth finding out there.

More than a captain

Patrick Stewart was born in 1940 in Mirfield, a small mill town in West Yorkshire. His childhood was difficult, and he spoke openly about it later in life. He turned that pain into decades of public campaigning against domestic violence.

He found the stage young and never really left it. In 1966 he joined the Royal Shakespeare Company, and he spent years playing kings, villains and fools in front of live audiences. That training shows in everything he did afterwards: the voice, the stillness, the way a single pause could carry a whole scene.

In 1987 he was cast as Jean-Luc Picard in Star Trek: The Next Generation. Plenty of people doubted that a bald, middle-aged British stage actor could lead an American TV franchise. He proved them wrong across seven seasons and four feature films, and the show became one of the most loved in television history.

In 2000 a new generation met him as Professor Charles Xavier in X-Men, the patient teacher who believed people who were different deserved a place in the world. He played the role for nearly two decades, ending with a heartbreaking turn in Logan in 2017. In 2010 he was knighted for services to drama.

Then, at nearly 80, he did something few actors ever get to do. He came back to Picard in Star Trek: Picard, which ran for three seasons from 2020 to 2023. We got to see our captain grow old, doubt himself, and still choose to do the right thing.

What Picard stood for

Picard was a different kind of captain. He reached for diplomacy before phasers, and he treated every new species as something to understand rather than defeat. He read Shakespeare, loved archaeology, and listened to the people around him before he gave an order.

A few moments stay with me:
• The Measure of a Man. Picard defends the android Data in a hearing over whether he is property or a person. It is a courtroom drama about what makes a mind worthy of rights, and it feels more relevant every year.
• The Inner Light. A probe lets Picard live an entire lifetime on a dying planet in what is only minutes on the Enterprise. He comes back carrying a family, a community and a flute. It may be the best hour Star Trek ever made.
• Chain of Command. Captured and tortured, Picard refuses to say he sees five lights when there are four. It is a lesson in holding on to the truth when everything pushes you to give it up.

Even his catchphrases said something about leadership. “Make it so” meant he trusted his crew to carry out the plan. “Engage” meant the thinking was done, and now we go.

Above all, Picard showed that exploration could be a mature, curious, peaceful act. The point of going out there was never conquest. It was to learn, to meet others, and to come back a little wiser.

From the bridge to the launch pad

Star Trek has always had a habit of turning viewers into scientists. Engineers, astronomers and astronauts have said for decades that the show is why they first looked up. Mae Jemison, the first African American woman in space, credited Star Trek as an early inspiration, and she later appeared in an episode of The Next Generation, sharing the screen with Picard’s crew.

That loop between fiction and reality is the part of his legacy I care about most. Picard made the future look like a place you’d want to live: a place where curiosity was a career and science was something you did together. For a lot of kids, and a lot of adults, that was enough to start asking real questions.

For me it started small. I wanted to know how a ship actually gets to orbit, why some missions take years to reach their target, and who decides where we go next. One question led to the next, and space exploration became a lasting interest rather than a TV backdrop.

The real version is slower and messier than warp drive, but it is happening. Space telescopes are looking back to the earliest galaxies, robots are roaming Mars, and crewed missions are aiming at the Moon again. None of it is the Enterprise. All of it carries a little of the spirit Picard stood for: go carefully, go together, and go to learn.

Engage

It’s strange to grieve someone you never met. But Patrick Stewart spent decades in our living rooms, and for many of us he helped shape who we became. He gave us a captain who led with his mind and his conscience, and he showed us what a decent person in charge could look like.

The best way I know to honour him is to keep doing what Picard taught me to do. Stay curious. Listen before deciding. Treat the unknown as something to understand, not something to fear. And keep looking up.

Thank you, Sir Patrick. The bridge is quieter tonight, but the course you set is still laid in.

Engage.

Image: Patrick Stewart at the 2019 San Diego Comic-Con International. Credit: Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

 

 

Artist's impression of the CD-35 2722 system, with a Jupiter-mass moon-like object orbiting a brown dwarf

 

A moon usually has a simple job description: it goes around a planet. The candidate announced this week in the CD-35 2722 system breaks that shortcut. It appears to orbit a brown dwarf, while the brown dwarf itself circles a small star. The outer object has at least the mass of Jupiter. The middle object is about 37 times as massive as Jupiter, too heavy to fit the usual planet category but too light to sustain hydrogen fusion like a star, according to the European Southern Observatory’s release.

That makes the system a three-level orbiting arrangement, but “exomoon” is not quite the right label. The authors of the Nature study call it a planetary-mass exosatellite and describe the result as evidence, not a final, uncontested discovery. That caution matters. The object was not photographed as a separate dot. Researchers inferred its pull from the motion of its brown-dwarf host.

Artist’s impression of CD-35 2722. The star is at left, the brown dwarf is in the foreground, and the newly found object is near the centre. Credit: ESO/M. Kornmesser. ESO image page.

Astronomers have found more than 6,000 exoplanets, but no moon orbiting one of those planets has been confirmed without serious dispute. A planet’s moon is smaller and fainter than the planet, and the planet is already lost in the glare of its star. The geometry makes the signal hard to isolate. In CD-35 2722, the host is a brown dwarf, which is dimmer than an ordinary star and can be observed directly with instruments built for high-contrast infrared work. That changes the observing problem, even if it does not make the interpretation easy.

The result also tests how useful familiar categories are. A moon-like object is defined by the body it orbits, while a planet is often defined by its mass, formation history, or the way it dominates its orbit. Those definitions work tolerably well in the Solar System. They become awkward when a Jupiter-mass body circles a brown dwarf. Calling it a moon describes its orbit. Calling it a planet describes its scale. Calling it an exosatellite avoids pretending that one word settles the physics.

There is a practical reason to care about the label debate. If this detection holds up, it gives observers a new class of target. They can search for satellites around directly imaged brown dwarfs, where the host’s spectrum is accessible and the companion’s gravitational effect may be measurable. The sample will be small, but the method is concrete enough to test.

CD-35 2722 is a star roughly half the Sun’s mass, located about 73 light-years away in the constellation Columba. Its companion, CD-35 2722 B, was directly imaged years ago and is a brown dwarf. The ESO team describes the brown dwarf as orbiting the star on a timescale of about 5,000 years, which means that the star and brown dwarf barely move across a human observing campaign. The newly reported object is the fast-moving part of the system: it circles the brown dwarf.

The researchers used the Very Large Telescope’s CRIRES+ instrument, a high-resolution infrared spectrograph. The observing programme monitored the brown dwarf from October 2023 through January 2025, according to the open version of the paper. The aim was to measure tiny changes in the brown dwarf’s radial velocity, the component of its motion toward or away from Earth.

A satellite changes that velocity because the brown dwarf does not sit perfectly still. Both bodies orbit their common centre of mass. If the satellite is on one side of that balance point, the brown dwarf moves slightly toward us; half an orbit later it moves slightly away. The resulting pattern is periodic. In principle, it is the same basic idea used to discover the first exoplanets around Sun-like stars, applied one level down to a brown dwarf and its companion.

The analysis found a periodic signal consistent with at least one planetary-mass body orbiting CD-35 2722 B. The Nature paper reports a Jupiter-mass exosatellite candidate. “Candidate” is doing real work here. A radial-velocity curve can be distorted by instrumental systematics, activity in the brown dwarf’s atmosphere, or an incomplete model of the system. The team therefore presents the finding as strong evidence rather than an official first exomoon announcement.

The system’s arrangement is unusual even before the terminology begins. The star is the largest body. The brown dwarf is a companion that formed or evolved in a regime between planets and stars. The outer body has the mass of a gas giant but occupies the satellite role. In our Solar System, Jupiter’s moons are far less massive than Jupiter. Here, the supposed moon may be a substantial fraction of its host’s mass, so the two-body orbit is better understood as a binary pair nested inside a wider stellar orbit.

Follow-up observations will have to answer several questions. Does the signal repeat with the same period? Can independent instruments recover it? Does the inferred mass remain stable when the orbit and brown-dwarf properties are fitted together? And can the system’s long-term dynamics keep the outer body bound while the brown dwarf travels around the star? A few clean observing seasons could do more for the claim than a louder headline would.

Radial velocity does not measure an object’s mass directly. It measures the line-of-sight speed of the body being observed. The mass estimate comes from fitting an orbit to the velocity curve and combining that fit with the host mass and orbital geometry. If the orbit is viewed nearly face-on, the true companion mass can be larger than the minimum value inferred from the measured wobble. That is one reason the paper uses language such as “at least as massive as Jupiter.”

CRIRES+ helps by spreading infrared light into a detailed spectrum. Molecules in the brown dwarf’s atmosphere absorb particular wavelengths. As the dwarf moves, those absorption lines shift through the Doppler effect. The instrument tracks the shifts against a wavelength reference, while the analysis separates the brown dwarf’s motion from the Earth’s motion and from the instrument’s behaviour. The expected signal is small, so many individual spectral lines can be combined to improve the velocity estimate.

The nested orbit adds another layer. The brown dwarf’s broad, slow motion around the star is nearly constant over the observing window, while the satellite’s motion should be much faster. A useful model must account for both. It must also distinguish orbital motion from changing atmospheric patterns. Brown dwarfs are not quiet, featureless balls of gas: clouds and temperature variations can alter their spectra. A signal that survives those tests is much more persuasive than a visually pleasing curve.

Stability is a separate engineering-style constraint. The satellite must remain inside the brown dwarf’s gravitational sphere of influence, often approximated by its Hill sphere, while avoiding an orbit so close that tides or disruption become dominant. The star’s distant pull sets the outer boundary. A long-lived configuration needs room between those limits. The reported architecture remains useful even if the object is eventually reclassified: it gives dynamical modelers a real system to stress-test.

The CD-35 2722 result is best read as a careful detection claim, not as the end of the exomoon hunt. Researchers have found a periodic radial-velocity signal in the directly imaged brown dwarf CD-35 2722 B, and the signal is consistent with a companion at least as massive as Jupiter. That is enough to make the system worth following. It is not enough to erase every alternative explanation.

The interesting part is the mismatch between orbit and category. The object behaves like a moon because it circles a brown dwarf. Its mass makes it look like a planet. The brown dwarf itself occupies the middle ground between planet and star. Nature has supplied a system that forces the vocabulary to catch up with the observations.

For now, “planetary-mass exosatellite” is the honest name. More observations will decide whether it becomes the first broadly accepted exomoon-like detection, or a well-measured example of how messy planetary systems can be.